Customer reviews for Women's Brooks Flat
This product is no longer available. Continue shopping at Sperry Top-Sider.
Women's Brooks Flat
The ballerina of the season. Sweet and sexy with lucky penny detail. Flat-out pretty with flirty dresses and leggy looks.
Overall rating:
(25 reviews) 25
Rating breakdown 25 reviews
5 stars
11
4 stars
7
3 stars
3
2 stars
2
1 star
2
19 out of 25(76%)reviewers recommend this product.
Customer reviews for Women's Brooks Flat
Review 1 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
1
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits 1/2 Size Too Small
Width:
Fits True to Size
Limey From: Coral Gables, Florida
Size and Width Ordered: 10M
Age:55-65
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
It's too short compared to other shoes the same size
PostedNovember 27, 2012
I loved the look of this shoe. But the height of the shoe tapers at the toe, rather than being rounded or squared off, making it too short for the size.
I had to return it, but it was not available in a larger size, so I am out $11 for UPS shipping, with nothing to show for it.
By the way, Sperry only paid $5.00 to ship it to me. So what's up with that?
I had to return it, but it was not available in a larger size, so I am out $11 for UPS shipping, with nothing to show for it.
By the way, Sperry only paid $5.00 to ship it to me. So what's up with that?
Share:
Review 2 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
3
/
5
Style:
4
/
5
Quality:
3
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Anonymous No, I do not recommend this product.
Cute, but likely not the best Sperry value
PostedNovember 15, 2012
These have very little support--unlike most Sperry's. I was expecting a bit more cushion (which I need). These are cute and fit well. However, you can get very similar shoes elsewhere for half the price.
2 of 2 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 3 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
Jassy61 From: Charlotte, NC
Size and Width Ordered: 10
Age:45-54
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Great Shoe, dressed up or down!
PostedNovember 13, 2012
Bought the beige patent to wear with slacks and skirts for work. They feel great and have a good cushioned sole. Also look great with jeans. My new favorite go to shoe!
Share:
Review 4 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
4
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
KayO From: Indianapolis, IN
Size and Width Ordered: 7.5M
Age:45-54
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Love it!
PostedNovember 8, 2012
This is my second pair of these shoes. I get tons of compliments whenever I wear them. The only change I would make is for more arch support. Otherwise, they are wonderful.
Share:
Review 5 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
4
/
5
Style:
4
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits Narrow
Binnie From: Georgia
Size and Width Ordered: 8M
Age:35-44
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Top Rated in my Book
PostedOctober 30, 2012
Sperry's always been one of my favorite brands of shoes. They have lasted for many years as a quality name. These shoes are classy with a touch of style with my work wardrobe. They are a little pricy, they are sometimes worth the money.
Share:
Review 6 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
1
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
2
/
5
Size:
Fits 1/2 Size Too Small
Width:
Fits Too Wide
aamg11 From: Chicago, IL
Size and Width Ordered: 7M
Age:25-34
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
No, I do not recommend this product.
Weird sizing
PostedOctober 9, 2012
I loved these and really wanted to keep them, but they don't fit like my other Sperrys at all. The front is very squished and the metal piece presses down on the toes, and then they're really wide so they don't give any support for the whole middle of the foot. I was SO bummed but I had to return them.
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 7 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
2
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
1
/
5
Size:
Fits 1/2 Size Too Small
kelgirl620 From: Pittsburgh, PA
Size and Width Ordered: 9M
Age:25-34
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
No, I do not recommend this product.
Smelly!
PostedOctober 8, 2012
I love how the boat shoes do not smell and you can wear them barefooted. I was hoping it was because of the quality of the materials that were used to make the shoes. I bought 3 pair of these shoes in hopes that they were also okay to wear without socks.....I've worn the black ones three times and they stink!! Very disappointed!
Share:
Review 8 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
1
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits 1/2 Size Too Small
Sailsofcc From: Cape Cod, MA
Size and Width Ordered: 9m
Age:45-54
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
No, I do not recommend this product.
cute, but not comfortable
PostedOctober 5, 2012
Was really disappointed in the comfort and fit of these shoes as they pinched through out the whole toe area. Granted, I only wore them once so maybe they will stretch out. First time I have had this happen with a pair of Sperry's. I also found the color a little more purplish then blue, but they looked good enough with the blue pants I bought them to go with.
Share:
Review 9 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
1
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
classicpenny From: Washington State
Size and Width Ordered: 7.5M and 11M
Age:25-34
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
No, I do not recommend this product.
True color of shoe was not as described.
PostedSeptember 25, 2012
I ordered two pairs of BLUE shoes from you
(order number 228545636). Your website text clearly said the shoes were BLUE; and your website picture showed a picture of BLUE shoes.
(order number 228545636). Your website text clearly said the shoes were BLUE; and your website picture showed a picture of BLUE shoes.
HOWEVER, WHEN THEY CAME, THE SHOES WERE PURPLE!!
So I took some pictures of real true blue shoes sitting next to your newly arrived "purple" shoes; but in the pictures, your "purple" shoes were -incredibly (to me)- BLUE! (So I didn't send the picture.)
And now I can see how this happened: the pictures taken by YOUR camera ALSO showed the shoes to be blue - so you called them "blue" on your website, since after all they LOOKED blue in the picture.
I don't want a refund, but I AM very frustrated: it will be much more difficult for us to match purple than blue would have been.
2 of 2 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 10 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
4
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits Narrow
Amelda From: Southwest Florida
Size and Width Ordered: 6.5 medium
Age:Over 65
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Great little shoe. Have purchased in several colors.
PostedAugust 10, 2012
Great little shoe. They go with so many things. I don't travel without at least one pair of them in my suitcase.
2 of 3 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 11 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Mrs. S From: North Carolina
Size and Width Ordered: 7M
Age:55-65
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Comfortable and cute
PostedAugust 6, 2012
Sperry has turned practical shoes into pretty shoes. They are fun to wear, and come in a variety of colors. Who could ask for more? Keep up the good work, Sperry!
Share:
Review 12 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
Anonymous Yes, I recommend this product.
A classic shoe
PostedAugust 2, 2012
I purchased this flat in the beige and I absolutely adore it! The fit is comfortable, the patent leather is high quality, and it is a classic style that I can wear everyday. My favorite feature of this shoe is the squishy insole. It makes it very comfortable to walk in. Yes, this shoe is pricey but it is an investment that is worth every penny.
2 of 2 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 13 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
Sintia From: San Francisco, CA
Size and Width Ordered: 7 1/2
Age:18-24
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
So Cute and Comfortable!
PostedJuly 17, 2012
I have never loved a pair of shoes more, I bought these in the red and they are adorable! I get so many compliments! I am an event planner so cute comfy shoes are a must and these are perfect. I always feel so stylish wearing these, I almost feel like they give me a boost of confidence, might just be the red, but also feeling comfortable in them. I have pretty wide feet and they make my feet look slimmer. I definitely recommend these! I am actually on this website now because I want to get these in leopard next :)
3 of 3 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 14 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
RollerDerbyGirl1234 From: Wyoming
Size and Width Ordered: 8.5M
Age:18-24
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Great Quality, and looks awesome
PostedJune 22, 2012
I got these in the nude color, I was almost worried they'd look a little grandma-ish in such a bland color, but they actually look classy and not at all like I worried. They are excellent quality, well constructed, comfortable, but most of all, pretty and easy to match with outfits. They add a little more class to any outfit, and you don't have to sacrifice comfort for style with these. Only drawback, and not because of the shoe itself, was that the box they were shipped in was about twice the size of the shoe box, and one fell out and was banging around during shipping, so the wonderful shiny patent leather was a bit scuffed when I got them. Still liked them too much to return them though, didn't want to wait for another pair!
Share:
Review 15 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits 1/2 Size Too Big
Width:
Fits True to Size
Anonymous Yes, I recommend this product.
Cute
PostedJune 21, 2012
It is a bit too big - I could probably go down a 1/2 a size. Overall super comfy and cute (in leopard).
Share:
Review 16 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
Anonymous Yes, I recommend this product.
This shoe is really nice.
PostedJune 14, 2012
Love the shoe. I have it in leopard print. So very comfortable.
Share:
Review 17 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
4
/
5
Style:
4
/
5
Quality:
4
/
5
Size:
Fits 1/2 Size Too Big
Width:
Fits Narrow
Anonymous From: Minnesota
Size and Width Ordered: 8.5M
Age:25-34
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Blue Suede is more purple
PostedMay 10, 2012
I was a little disappointed when I opened the box and saw the color. It was more purple than blue.
3 of 4 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 18 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Babs From: Troy, MI
Size and Width Ordered: 8.5 M
Age:45-54
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Adorable and stylish
PostedMay 8, 2012
I tried these on during a trip in January at a Sperry store and decided against getting them due to the price. Upon my return home I still obsessed about these shoes and finally broke down and bought them from the website and regardless of the price, am glad I did!! I bought the navy/white/platinum and know I will get a lot of use out of them, particularly for the spring/summer months!! I've worn them a few times and they are extremely comfortable and nice looking with dress slacks, jeans or capris!! Happy purchase!!
Share:
Review 19 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Size:
Fits 1 Size Too Big
Width:
Fits Too Wide
Pcon From: Austin, TX
Size and Width Ordered: 7 M
Age:55-65
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
No, I do not recommend this product.
Trendy look but overly spacious
PostedMay 2, 2012
Since i could not locate this style in any of the stores in my area, I resorted to ordering them on-line. I ordered my normal size (7), but when they arrived, cute and trendy as they were, they were WAY too large in both length and width. Ended up sending them back--sniff, sniff. Would not re-order without being able to try on first.
1 of 2 found this review helpful.
Share:
Review 20 for Women's Brooks Flat
Overall Rating:
Comfort:
5
/
5
Style:
5
/
5
Quality:
5
/
5
Size:
Fits True to Size
Width:
Fits True to Size
KelB From: NJ
Size and Width Ordered: 8M
Age:35-44
Gender:Female
Product Use:Casual wear
Yes, I recommend this product.
Adorable & comfy
PostedApril 30, 2012
These shoes are adorable. Super comfortable, and the patterned ones add a little oomph to your wardrobe. A little pricey, but otherwise highly recommend.
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share:
